Old Software Flaw Helped Create Su-30 and Su-35
Introduction
In 2002, a severe crash during a standard test flight ended the Su-37 “Terminator” prototype programme, but it also set the stage for the future of Russian fighter aircraft. The Su-37, known for its impressive manoeuvrability, is close to changing aerial combat dynamics. However, a software issue led to its failure, altering Russian aviation history significantly.
Although the Su-37 programme was discontinued, the insights gained and technologies developed from that unfortunate prototype have significantly influenced the design and capabilities of subsequent Russian fighter aircraft, particularly the Su-30 and Su-35. These advanced jets, now essential to Russia’s air force, owe a lot to the innovations and challenges of the Su-37.
The 2002 Su-37 Crash: A Critical Moment in Russian Aviation
The Su-37 prototype had the promise to be among the top fighter jets globally. With advanced thrust-vectoring engines and modern avionics, it showed remarkable agility, including the famed Pugachev Cobra, a daring aerial manoeuvre that impressed spectators. Yet, during a test flight near Zhukovsky, tragedy occurred.
As the skilled test pilot performed intricate manoeuvres, a failure in the aircraft’s flight control system provided incorrect data for the fly-by-wire system. A malfunctionlfunction led to the Su-37 losing stability, prompting the pilot to eject just moments before the crash.
An investigation determined that a key onboard computer failure prompted the incident, sending erratic signals to the thrust-vectoring engines and making the aircraft uncontrollable. This crash not only ended the Su-37 programme but also highlighted flaws in Russia’s experimental flight control systems.
From Setback to Advancement: Technology Improvements in Russian Fighters
The Su-37’s unfortunate end did not negate the technological advances it showcased. In fact, many of these innovations were vital in developing the Su-30 and Su-35, the most capable fighter jets in Russia today.
Thrust-Vectoring Engines: A Key to Enhanced Maneuverability
One prominent aspect of the Su-37 was its thrust-vectoring engines, which allowed the aircraft to modify its exhaust flow for exceptional agility. This technology became a fundamental feature in Russia’s next-generation fighters, particularly the Su-30MKI and Su-35.
The Su-30, which initially had AL-31FP engines, directly benefited from the thrust-vectoring technology trialled on the Su-37. The Su-35 advanced this further by incorporating the more powerful AL-41F1S engines, which improved thrust, efficiency, and fuel economy—boosting both aircraft speed and endurance.
Fly-by-Wire Systems: Enhancing Control and Exactness
Another important technology tested in the Su-37 was its fly-by-wire system, which allowed for accurate control over the aircraft’s unstable design. This system, which manages the aircraft’s flight controls electronically, formed the basis for the sophisticated control mechanisms seen in the Su-35.
The Su-35, like the Su-37, uses intricate algorithms and precise digital controls, making it one of the most nimble and responsive fighters worldwide. The fly-by-wire system has greatly improved, providing even better performance and control, especially during high-stakes aerial manoeuvres.
Advancements in Radar and Cockpit Technology
Russian military aircraft later incorporated various advanced technologies explored by the Su-37.
Radar Systems: Improved Target Detection
The Su-37 featured the “Bars” radar, which was later adopted for the Su-30. This radar enhanced target tracking and detection abilities, which are crucial in modern air battles. The Su-35, however, had the “Irbis-E” radar added, providing a longer range and allowing the tracking of multiple targets at once. These improvements gave a clear advantage in air-to-air and air-to-ground fighting.
Cockpit Features: A Focus on the Pilot
The Su-37 was one of the initial Russian jets to use multi-function displays (MFDs) and updated weapons control, features now common in military planes. The Su-35 took these cockpit features further by including advanced digital tools that help with situational awareness. Helmet-mounted cueing systems enable pilots to target enemy planes just by looking at them, which offers a tactical edge in combat.
Missed Opportunities: The Su-37’s Unfulfilled Promise
If the Su-37 project had continued, it might have significantly impacted Russian and global aviation. With more enhancements, the aircraft could have established new benchmarks for agility and control, making it a strong competitor to Western fighters like the F-22 Raptor.
Maneuverability and Stealth: A Dynamic Duo
over stealth. While U.S. fighters such as the F-22 and F-35 prioritised stealth, the Su-37’s advanced engines and fly-by-wire system might have allowed it to excel in dogfights, outmanoeuvring opponents in any situation.
With further progress, the Su-37 would most likely have been equipped with stronger and more efficient engines, potentially including stealth features to enhance its role as a versatile fighter for both air superiority and deep strike tasks. A lower radar profile and better materials could have made the Su-37 a formidable presence in both air and ground battles.
The Future of Russian Fighters
If the Su-37 had continued, it could have laid the groundwork for Russia’s fifth-generation fighter initiative, accelerating the development of technologies used in the Su-57. Its advancements in thrust vectoring, fly-by-wire technology, radar, and cockpit layout might have established it as a key player in Russian aviation for this century, offering a technological edge over Western aircraft.
Final Thoughts: The Legacy of the Su-37
The 2002 accident involving the Su-37 “Terminator” ended a promising phase in Russian aviation. Nevertheless, the technical gains from the prototype were carried over to later planes like the Su-30 and Su-35. The Su-37’s advancements in thrust-vectoring engines, fly-by-wire technology, radar, and cockpit systems continue to influence the design of contemporary Russian fighters, preserving its legacy.
Had its cancellation not occurred, the Su-37 could’ve become a legendary fighter that revolutionised aerial combat. Instead, the unrealised potential highlights the balance of risks and rewards in advanced military aviation.
References
- Russian Aerospace: The Su-30 and Su-35
- Flight Global—The Legacy of the Su-37
- Military Aviation – Su-37 Development and Crash
- Jane’s Defence Weekly—Russian Fighter Evolution
About the Author
